In the everyday use of my HP 910 I had to deal with the bad quirks along with the good quality elements of the device such as the wide form factor, lackluster speaker, mediocre web browser, marginal call quality, cumbersome voice command software and horrible video recording for a potentially good mobile camera. I only put up with these issues for mainly two reasons: the great qwerty performance and the lack of Mac sync software for my Nokia phones. At one point I did think that a touchscreen was another benefit, but often times with WM it was nothing more than a fragile liability for something to malfunction. This is especially true considering the plastic screen surface versus the optical glass of the iPhone. I just wanted a small and compact model that offered the best in what I need, data and messaging support. The 910 was too wide and sometimes felt like I was holding a graham cracker to my face while talking on a voice call. It seemed that there was too much trouble to do the simplest things like profile changing and voice dialing. The HP Voice Command software is not bad but needs more improvement overall. There were too many rules with how a command had to be said to the device to even bother with it, so I completely ignored it without a problem...and didn't miss using it AT ALL! The only phone that I can honestly say surpasses Nokia in call quality is the Motorola Q Global a.k.a. the Q9h. With its Crystal Talk technology there is absolutely no doubt that it is the most amazing handset to carry a phone conversation with no reception or volume issues whatsoever, but Nokia isn't too far behind with its sound quality either. I wish the HP 910 was at least a level below where the Nokia is in this regard, but this isn't possible since it was plagued by the same volume issues as most WM phones. Even when I did my best to find a perfect position for the earpiece there was always a need to increase the volume past the maximum limit, especially in noisy surroundings. My E71-2 so far has had no problems in giving me the most promising volume feedback in voice calls and speakerphone usage! Callers sound very clear and for a change I don't have to struggle to find a perfect listening spot for the earpiece. The Internet Explorer web browser was ultimately a sufficient browser, but in comparison to Opera Mobile 8.65 there was no contest for which had the best user interface. Lack of tabbed browsing and flash support posed a problem, but a major and most shocking problem was when it didn't support Bank of America mobile. This still is an enigma to me since my Treo 750's IE to this day doesn't have any trouble in accessing my bank accounts at all. The S60 browser is by no means perfect either, but it performs well for what I need and the enabling of flash makes it even more of a joy to use (it can at least access my mobile banking). The multimedia experience with an average WM device is always destined to be faced with compromises and tolerances for the sake of holding on to the amazing office app and messaging functions. Unless a smartphone owner was strictly focused on only messaging and voice calls there was definitely a yearning for a speaker and camera that was at least enough for good quality media content. Even though a WM device could boast a 3 megapixel lens, it was commonplace to find that it only matched the 2 megapixel units in the grade of its pictures. Video recording with WM is not even worth mentioning at this point since it is such an unfulfilled endeavor. Nokia has been and always will the champion in this field, even with the E71-2 camera that is slightly lesser than the N95s, N82s and the E90.
Even though I did have high aspirations to write the next best poetry anthology from a mobile office app, I was only kidding myself. Whether it be with this E71-2, my E90 or Treo 750, a smaller screen is not the place to try and write a research paper. I have learned that emails are the extent of my madness when it comes to writing on the dimensions of a smartphone screen, and that anything more should be reserved for my MacBook Pro...or Toshiba Satellite P305. As marvelous as it is to type for lengthy periods on the HP's qwerty, this huge benefit was overwhelmed by the inconvenience of unstable performance and cumbersome handling.
To now have this Nokia E71-2 is definitely a wish come true for me. I first thought about the greatness of a 3G enabled Nokia device when I first purchased the E90 a while back, but it seemed that Nokia had its focus on the overseas market instead of the US. As AT&T's 3G network started to be unveiled in different metropolitan areas including my own hometown area of Hampton Roads, the WM devices immediately took the advantage of this new fast data capability. Sliding qwerty models and WM enabled Treos suddenly all seemed to be having the last laugh over the multitudes of competing handsets damned to linger in EDGE forever and ever. I wonder if this was a factor in my decision to adopt WM as my main brand with the AT&T Tilt purchase. On this day it surely feels good to have the combination of high quality Nokia engineering paired with my high speed network and impressive word prediction software...FINALLY!! It would have been just as great to have the 3G enabled on my old E90, but this new E71-2 simply adds portability as icing on top of a most delectable cake...and I am looking to stuff my face with all the Nokia goodness!! Not to mention the new Missing Sync for Symbian that has finally solidified a reliable sync partnership with my Mac!!! It is refreshing to be able to have a device that FEELS like a phone and operates like my E90. To have voice dialing that ONLY requires a long press of the voice button and a contact name as it is entered in the listings, this beats having memorize a damn script like "Call so and so at mobile/work". To have this simplicity in even changing the active profile as well as other functions is such a welcomed and worthwhile feature from that unwieldy Windows Mobile interface. Nokia just works and it does so in a way that is most productive in a marriage of pristine hardware engineering and stable software implementing. As a leading producer of worthwhile products that embrace the good points of both multimedia AND office features, Nokia at this moment is number one at the top of my list once again!
TRENT
Sent from my Nokia E71-2