While I expected criticism of the touch interface for Symbian S60 5th edition, I hoped the opposite for the qwerty keypad. Just as I feared, there have already been accounts of the qwerty and d-pad being unpleasant to use due to their poor tactile feedback. While I love a reassuring "click" from typing on mobile devices, I think I can do without it as long as the keys don't feel like a stone slab. With my track record of previous gadgets, the qwerty still continues to be a most essential preference of mine that can easily claim the most importance. After reading a couple of online reviews and watching Steve Lichtfield's Phones Show netcast, I still have some initial concerns for the qwerty usability of the device. Well, let me take that back...I actually felt these concerns when I saw YouTube footage of N97 handsets being manufactured in a Nokia factory. I can still visualize that staff member who appeared to be placing a strip of flexible material onto where the qwerty was to be located. Quite frankly, my expectation for a high-quality keypad were dashed upon seeing such a sight. In the back of my mind I was horrified to imagine that Nokia would resort to using a cheap method for building a flagship device! Upon paying for such an expensive price for the N97, it is not unreasonable to expect a bit more than the bare minimum in regards to its craftsmanship. Not meaning to sound too critical, for I do realize that this model is truly worlds away from the low-cost, free upgrade flip phones of yesteryear. However, when the N97 is compared to current smartphones in the same pricing bracket, there should be no doubt of its being up to par. All I can do at this point is wait until the box arrives via courier.
Overall, I am hoping to maintain functionality comparable to my current E71 once I receive the N97. I am prepared to accept change that cannot be helped in certain situations, like the possible absence of efficient one-handed usage and compatibility with Nokia Messaging and Missing Sync for Symbian. It may take a while to adjust to leaving the form factor of the E71 with its quick access qwerty, but the slider may not be too bad on a daily basis. I did hear of a Messaging app version being available for S60 5th edition, but some previous online reviews from usage on the 5800 XpressMusic were not really promising. Having to return to the native messaging app will not be much of an inconvenience, considering the benefit of owning the N97. While I can be somewhat flexible in my acceptance of this new phone, having to deal with possible lack of Missing Sync may be more than I am willing to bear. I have also heard that there is no Apple iSync plug-in available at this time, but even if this was false I'd most likely still refuse to tolerate iSync's inconsistent performance. Nokia Sport Tracker would be great to have, but is only a luxury that can easily be replaced by the Nike Sport Kit that I continue to use with my iPod Touch. Unlocking Quickoffice should not be an issue since I can get my license transferred from the E71, and most of the other features in the menus should not be any different. A learning curve will definitely have to be in place to get accustomed to the new touch interface, but this only adds to the excitement!
In regards to multimedia, I am ecstatic to be returning to the NSeries line. While the E71 is sufficient, there's sometimes a lack of simple charm that is felt from its overall appearance in handling media. Galleries are bland when browsing photos and movies, and the sound from the mono speaker (though tolerable) leaves room for improvement. The E75 showed much more potential with its 3.5mm headphone jack and feature pack 2, but it suffered from a tiny screen and flat qwerty buttons. This N97 appears to blend every single feature that I would ever want in a Nokia!
I am also thankful to have had the opportunity to cancel my Amazon.com preorder for the white N97 and switch to the black instead. While white does have a flashy allure, it my be a bit too flashy for me. I can recall using the white E71 for a few days and feeling like I was playing with a toy instead of using a smartphone. I got much attention with the white, but it was usually from average phone users more interested in having a fashion accessory instead of a capable phone. I also didn't want to give the wrong impression of my character if I were to use this in a workplace environment. The difference from white to black can absolutely tread that fine line between "mobile professional" and "brat pack", but this only my opinion.
A week or two may be enough to determine whether the N97 is worth the effort to make the switch back to the NSeries, but we shall see. The days cannot go by fast enough as I await the arrival of my new Nokia!
TRENT
Sent from my Nokia E71
TRENT SENSE blogger/netcast host
trentonnsmith.blogspot.com
youtube.com/absolon3
5 comments:
Although it hasn't been published yet on its website, Sports Tracker is available for S60 5th ed. You can get it from several places, like for example here.
Also, by your remarks about the E75 and its sliding keyboard, I can't help but think that the recently leaked E72 would be a better fit for you than the N97.
I certainly understand your mentioning of the E72, but it doesn't seem to offer anything that is revolutionary when compared to the E71 I already have.
The N97 is a risk due to the sliding qwerty, but there is also the added benefit of using a brand new touch interface. Symbian S60 5th edition could be a positive or a negative gain for my usage, but I won't know until I try it.
Roberto: Thanks very much for the link to the Sports Tracker app!
turns out the E71i you were talking about is called the E72 w/ a 5mp AF camera, here is the promo:
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x9kznz_nokia-e72_tech
Lets hope Nokia don't release the N97 homescreen in a 5800 firmware upgrade. I know where my money would be going. N97 hasn't lit my fire so I think i'll take a chance on a 5800 or a 5530 though the lack of 3g on the latter would be a huge sacrafice. A 5MP 5800 in the 5530's body. . . .now theres a thought. .
Post a Comment